But wait? Where was 1.0?
Honestly, I launched Azelastine Academy 1.0 a bit too early, and it caused some weird issues once we started playing live. The story was going where it was supposed to, but a few problems popped up, and the campaign got stuck. Plus, some of my players had real‑life stuff come up, so I figured it was best to put things on pause for a bit.
I gave Daggerheart: Curse of Strahd Edition a try, but I’ll admit I don’t often run premade modules. The excitement was there, yet I found myself getting lost while reading and trying to adapt their intentions to what was actually happening at the table. So, apologies everyone — I’m pausing this one as well, and I’ll come back to redo it someday.
Now that I’ve explored Daggerheart, I’ve been asking myself whether I prefer it or D&D 5E. I genuinely love how Daggerheart empowers players and shapes the story, but deep down…

I think I’m a D&D person at heart. So it’s settled: I’m sticking with D&D, but I’ll be pulling in ideas from other systems to keep things fresh. Some people might not love that choice, but the d20 system is fun — and I’ll be swapping it out for the Duality system: 2d12 with Fear and Hope.
How?
My temporary plan is pretty simple. Use your own judgment if you decide to try this approach yourself. The d20 system is great, but I really enjoy the flexibility and feel of the Duality dice adjustments.
The 5e/D20 system:
How it works: You roll a single 20-sided die, add your modifiers, and try to meet or beat a target number (Difficulty Class/DC). Advantage/Disadvantage, roll extra d20 take the better one, or take the lower one for disadvantage.
Probability: It offers a flat probability curve, meaning every number on the die (1 through 20) has an equal (5%) chance of being rolled. The 1d20 bell-curve is 10.5 (average roll).
Tone: Highly tactical and math-heavy. Natural 20s mean critical success; Natural 1s mean critical failure. It is classic and reliable, but can sometimes feel “swingy” or overly punishing.
Duality Die system:
How it works: You roll two distinct 12-sided dice. One represents Hope (your positive actions/luck), and the other represents Fear (adverse narrative complications). You add the two dice together with your modifiers to beat a difficulty threshold, but the specific values of the dice drive the story.
Probability: Rolling 2d12 creates a bell-curve centered around 13, resulting in more consistent and predictable rolls than a single d20.
Narrative Outcomes: Depending on which die is higher, you can succeed with Hope, succeed with Fear, fail with Hope, or fail with Fear. For example, even if your total is high enough to pass a check, if the Fear die is higher, the Game Master (GM) gains a “Fear token” to use later in the game to complicate the story.
Tone: Narrative-forward. It constantly injects plot complications and character resources into every single roll, keeping the pace exciting and story-focused
We are completely replacing the standard d20 with Duality Dice (inspired by Daggerheart). This shifts the game from a flat binary “pass/fail” to a dynamic system driven by narrative tension, chaos, and a resource economy called Hope and Fear.
Because 2d12 creates a bell curve with a higher average roll, all NPC Armor Classes (AC) and Difficulty Classes (DCs) are increased by +2 to keep the math balanced.
⚔️ The Core Mechanic
Instead of a d20, roll two differently colored d12s simultaneously:
- ⚪ The Hope Die (Pick a bright color)
- ⚫ The Fear Die (Pick a dark color)
Add the two d12s together, add your standard 5e modifiers (Strength, Proficiency, etc.), and compare the total to the DC or AC. Which individual die rolled higher determines the narrative twist:
1. Success with Hope (Total passes DC/AC + Hope Die is higher)
- The Result: You succeed beautifully.
- The Mechanic: You gain 1 Hope Point.
2. Success with Fear (Total passes DC/AC + Fear Die is higher)
- The Result: “Success at a Cost.” You achieve your goal, but a narrative complication or minor hitch occurs.
- The Mechanic: The DM gains 1 Fear Point.
3. Failure with Hope (Total misses DC/AC + Hope Die is higher)
- The Result: You fail the task, but there is a silver lining or a consoling positive outcome.
- The Mechanic: You still gain 1 Hope Point to soften the blow.
4. Failure with Fear (Total misses DC/AC + Fear Die is higher)
- The Result: A hard, clean failure. Things go from bad to worse.
- The Mechanic: The DM gains 1 Fear Point.
##💥 Critical Hits: Rolling Doubles
If you roll matching numbers on both d12s (e.g., double 3s, double 7s, double 12s), it is a Critical Success!
- The Narrative: An automatic, spectacular triumph regardless of modifiers or the DC.
- The Mechanic: Deals standard 5e critical damage (double damage dice) AND you either instantly clear all current Fear from the DM’s pool or gain 1 Hope Point.
- Note: At an 8.3% chance (compared to 5e’s 5%), expect combat to feel significantly more heroic!
🔄 Replacing Advantage & Disadvantage: Hope vs. Fear
We are completely removing standard 5e Advantage/Disadvantage. Instead, players spend Hope and the DM spends Fear to manipulate the dice using a 1d6 Modifier Die.
(Note: The 1d6 only changes the final math; you still look only at the original two d12s to see if the roll was “With Hope” or “With Fear.”)
⚪ Using Hope
- The Cap: A player can hold a maximum number of Hope points equal to their Character Level (e.g., a Level 3 Bard can hold 3 Hope).
- The Effect: Spend 1 Hope before rolling to add +1d6 to your total.
- Teamwork: Other players can spend their own Hope to assist you! This effect is stackable up to a maximum of +2d6 per roll.
⚫ Using Fear
- The Cap: The DM can hold up to 10 Fear points (for party levels 1–9) or 20 Fear points (once at least one player hits level 10+).
- The Effect: The DM can spend 1 Fear to roll an extra 1d6 and subtract it from your total. The DM can only apply 1 Fear per roll.
Why we’re doing this: This system beautifully bridges 5e’s tactical combat with a collaborative, improvisational storytelling style. It gives us a constant stream of awesome narrative hooks (“You pick the lock, but with Fear, so your tool snaps just as the tumblers click…”) while giving you guys more active control over your destiny.
Let me know if there’s any questions 🙂
yanger